Thrift Store Book Review
I picked up a book, What Should I Do With My Life? by Po Bronson,
the other day at a Salvation Army for eighty cents. I thought it was a good price for some casual reading. As you may know, I’m in a bit of a transitional stage in my “career, and I find a guilty pleasure in picking apart the ideological work that goes on self-help book. Perhaps an eighty-cent book might help me help myself, at any rate.
What Should I Do With My Life? is not a self-help book, although I suspect its audience – real or imagined – is largely the same. I might call it inspirational literature. It consists of short vignettes that describe folks who have found careers through paths both tortuous and torturous. It reads a little bit like lefty portraits by the likes of Barbara Ehrenreich except each of the subjects find a job they can tolerate that pays the bills.
I doubt that Bronson intended the book as a conservative response to Mother Jones or The Texas Observer, but halfway through, the theme of the book seems rather conservative. Bronson notes that he chose the somewhat deterministic title question intentionally – it suggests individuals have a particular role in society or family to perform. Unlike many career guides which encourage readers to open their minds to a broad swath possibilities, its case studies relate how others have leveraged existing interests or experience to move on to a new career stage. While this provides a nice antidote to the cheeriness blue-sky career books, it presents something of a grim vision for a reader who has regretted some past career choices. The message of the book so far seems to be “stay where you are and be content until the next opportunity comes along. You are where you are because you’re supposed to be there.”
The book’s portraits certainly acknowledge particular careers can be bad fits for particular people, but I think its emphasis on circumstance, rather than self-discovery comes off as a bit too preachy and perhaps a call to mediocrity.